Items related to Comparative Media Policy, Regulation and Governance...

Comparative Media Policy, Regulation and Governance in Europe – Unpacking the Policy Cycle - Softcover

D′haenens, Leen; Sousa, Helena; Trappel, Josef

 
9781783208869: Comparative Media Policy, Regulation and Governance in Europe – Unpacking the Policy Cycle

Synopsis

This book offers a comprehensive overview of the current European media in a period of disruptive transformation. It maps the full scope of contemporary media policy and industry activities while also assessing the impact of new technologies and radical changes in distribution and consumption on media practices, organizations, and strategies. Combining a critical assessment of media systems with a thematic approach, it can serve as a resource for scholars or as a textbook, as well as a source of good practices for steering media policy, international communication, and the media landscape across Europe.

"synopsis" may belong to another edition of this title.

About the Author

Leen d'Haenens is professor at the Institute for Media Studies and vice-dean of the Faculty of Social Sciences at the University of Leuven, Belgium. Helena Sousa is professor of communication sciences at the Communication and Society Research Centre and dean of the Social Sciences School at the University of Minho, Portugal. Josef Trappel is professor of media policy and media economics and head of the Department of Communication Research at the University of Salzburg, Austria.

Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved.

Comparative Media Policy, Regulation and Governance in Europe

Unpacking the Policy Cycle

By Leen d'Haenens, Helena Sousa, Josef Trappel

Intellect Ltd

Copyright © 2018 Intellect Ltd
All rights reserved.
ISBN: 978-1-78320-886-9

CHAPTER 1

Testing the Boundaries: Evolving Norms and Troubling Trends for Journalism

Auksé Balc?ytiené, Karin Raeymaeckers and Elena Vartanova


This chapter joins the widespread debate about the fluctuating boundaries of journalism. It analyses arising pressures and obstacles, mostly related to technological and managerial approaches which, as seen in their outcomes, are working against journalism's autonomous performance and professionalization. Furthermore, the chapter touches upon the most recent effects also noticed in older democracies that political influence and provocations have on journalism: we refer to information wars and propaganda messages that (although outwardly looking as news journalism) are driven by purposes opposing the goals and ideals of the profession.

The discussion offered here applies an 'integrated' and 'contextually sensitive' methodology and poses a number of questions: How has our understanding of journalism changed in a highly interconnected and hybrid news environment where different actors and interests compete for each others' attention? Which factors are making the uppermost effect on changes registered in the profession and news output? What is so distinctive about journalism and how (and why) the journalistic culture and professionalism (and autonomy) should be preserved? What State and governance rules are required to safeguard journalism in 'post-fact' and 'post-truth' times?

To overcome the challenges revolving around the definition of 'news journalism', this chapter suggests that a combined approach in media policy design is required. Instead of focusing on isolated components observable within media systems, such as legal conditions ensuring media diversity and content pluralism, the new approach should incorporate the concepts of 'media literacy' or 'news literacy', which rest on the combination of situational factors (such as contextual settings for media performance), communication rights and freedom of expression (such as skills and competencies of media users). Only through such collective action, integrity in news logic, journalistic reasoning and professional news discourses can be obtained and sustained.


Introduction

Democracy needs informed citizens. To become engaged in democratic processes, citizens need access to reliable, accurate and verified information (Iyengar and Kinder 1987; Entman 1989; Graber et al. 1998; McNair 2000). A normative perspective to journalism rests on the idea that journalists operate in an institutionalized, morally and ethically defined professional Comparative Media Policy, Regulation and Governance in Europe framework. By selecting and presenting events as journalistic news, journalists set and define the societal agenda (Gans 2003).

Journalism and democracy are intrinsically correlated and indispensable for one another. As commonly disputed, journalism should give voice to the voiceless and provide a forum for public criticism and comment. Journalism must also carefully monitor those in power positions. It must analyse factual information in context and from a critical perspective. It should be independent, responsible and professional (in terms of mission and skills). It also must tackle societal needs and serve the public good, hence making clear distinctions between entertaining and empowering purposes of news remains as important as ever before, thus specifying journalism as a truly societal institution.

All the above-mentioned normative demands make journalism a key element in democracy with its exclusively defined and institutionalized professional role, ethical considerations and obligations (Nerone 2004; Christians et al. 2009). However, as noticed quite often, in daily practices these ambitions are not so clearly observed, followed or reproduced. As widely discussed, in times of crisis and volatility, abrupt changes (such as obliviousness to established ideals) in journalistic practices are identified, which all have a detrimental impact on journalistic professional values and autonomy (Schudson 2010; Lauk and Harro-Loit 2006). Whereas well-known, financially resilient and internationally respected media brands are still hoping to provide solid and correct information, the most of the mainstream media have diverted its attention from most of such obligations. Furthermore, citizen journalism and grassroots initiatives have partially taken over the role of criticism and of revealing information that the policy establishment wants to have unrevealed (Cooper 2006).

Appearances of new actors and intensification and growth of new types of news discourses are among the most indicative challengers in the journalistic field today. As noted by several authors, the likelihood of events and incidents to be reported in real-time has considerably increased; hence, serious effects were noticed on the lessened professional control and verification procedures in news making (Lewis et al. 2008a, 2008b; Reich 2009; Hermida 2015). As seen from various countries around the world, social media has turned into a truly global experience: today's audiences have interchanged conventional media to social networks, which, in turn, by supporting individualized and selective exposure to news, seriously undermine journalistic authority, previously held power and social influence (Hermida et al. 2012). Additionally, the monopoly of journalistic storytelling has been increasingly taken over by the new players (i.e. individual opinion makers taking part in collective construction of news narratives) in the networked communications arena (Petley 2011; Domingo and Le Cam 2015), which resulted in an overflow of opinionated and biased information, fake news, branded content, product placements and equivalent content production that embeds and packages messages of economic or even political stakeholders by using journalistic formats, genres and style.

Though such developments display diversified strategies applied by modern managers and (political) communicators, their social value appears to be critical since they turn the process of detection and distinction between original journalistic news and paid or manipulated messages (i.e. branded and embedded content, misinformation or even propaganda messages and various related informational attacks and fakes) into a very difficult, if not impossible, undertaking. By exploiting journalistic genres and destroying journalistic norms and values, such developments significantly influence professional standards and discourses. Consequently, previously safeguarded distinctive social borderlines between news journalism and other forms of transfer of messages (such as entrepreneurial communication, advertising, brand placement, promotional and marketing writing) appear to be shifting and considerably relaxed (Balcytiené and Harro-Loit 2009; Coddington 2015).

Whereas many of such changes are greatly inspired and linked to alterations in the business side of media operations, their outcomes have significant internal effects on the profession itself. It is not only that distinctions between 'proper' and 'profitable journalism' become synonymous or blurred (Wiik 2015). Even more, by slowly turning into a 'promotional industry', the news media increasingly appears to be less and less strict on its own managerial acts and functions. Although journalists still claim that they adhere to the role of critical bystander and eyewitness, many of the newsrooms appear to be less rigorous on their own misbehaviours (Balcytiené and Harro-Loit 2009). All this significantly affects professional ideals and norms and contributes to fragmentation within the profession: the professional journalistic ideology and boundaries of autonomous performance are shifting and new players and sources take over the authority in selection and construction of news. For instance, as the Lithuanian case demonstrates, by nominating its top popular writers as the best columnists of the year, one of the leading media companies certifies the shift towards 'opinionated production'; a similar trend is also seen when a group of politicians, academics or popular celebrities are assembled to form a cluster of often used opinion-makers and semi-journalists. In all, aiming for better financialization and searching for verified revenue models, the new 'ideology of managerialism' takes over specialized standards, eventually weakening the notion of journalist as an autonomous news gatherer and professional news gatekeeper.

Essentially, the economic reasoning has been given adequate scholarly attention and criticism; still, there is another shift in news making and distribution, which has only recently caught the attention. As verified by the rise of 'post-truth' and 'post-fact' revelations related to the latest political incidents and populist and manipulative informational acts (Mihailidis and Viotty 2017), the failing gatekeeping practices in a significant number of newsrooms when media space was allocated to fake news without further scrutiny and verification, pose even more urgent problems.

All things considered, journalism's previously vitally important democratic function in today's media environment becomes continuously disputed. Journalism increasingly appears to be only a part (and even a dramatically shrinking part) of media professions. In such a context, a number of questions remain to be asked: how meaningful is the news media's agenda? Who sets and shapes it – journalists, news managers, sources or undefined external influencers? How varied are the factors (and which are the strongest ones – internal or external influences – in today's communications arena) determining contemporary media discourses? How should professional journalism be defined and who takes part in the process of maintaining professionalism and adequate discourse in the profession?

The discussion offered below considers some of these questions and provides several potential versions of how current challenges to journalism's societal power and authority could be approached, identified and eliminated.


Mixed media, hybrid discourses and social contours of journalism

The trend of media convergence and its troubling outcomes, predominantly the rise of hybrid discourses and mixed media production as well as its effects on journalistic performance, have been widely discussed in different research studies. Scholarly debates are now focusing on the process of media convergence (Chadwick 2013) and journalism hybridization, which becomes evident in practices of journalistic genre mixing, more sensational and more entertainment-oriented reporting, blurring boundaries between verified news and misinformation and manipulations. Mixed discourses (hybrid discourses of misinformation, PR, advertisement and journalistic texts) proliferate in magazines, broadcast media and online networks and news sites. The critical side of such custom is that the dominance and wide availability of hybrid discourses legitimize the diminishing border between manipulations (promotional or intentionally fabricated text) and pure (or proper) journalism (Harro-Loit and Saks 2006; Balcytiené and Harro-Loit 2009; Wiik 2015; Balcytiené and Wadbring 2017).

Although different newsrooms still have and continue to apply systems of protection against external influences on journalism, there are obvious departures noticed from previously applied means and practices. As recognized, in Western European democracies professional media autonomy, quite traditionally, has been safeguarded by various mechanisms, such as legal provisions for freedom of the media as well as calls for media accountability and other shared standards of professionalism (Balcytiené et al. 2015). Today, as noticed, many news organizations appear to be silent about various issues of their existence, principally about the fact that there might be economic reasons and mechanisms that support a much more relaxed view on changing boundaries of journalism by promoting the so-called 'managerial type of thinking' in news production (Wiik and Andersson 2013; Compton and Benedetti, 2010).

Discussion on the changing boundaries of journalism has received extended attention in recent years, largely focusing on simultaneous developments that have shaken the news industry. In some debates these factors are listed as 'external' and are associated with broader sociocultural changes (linked with the intensification of individualized consumption as well as the rise of citizen journalism and social networking impacts on business models of media companies) (Hermida 2015; Heinrich 2011; Jonsson and Ornebring 2011). Also, there are others associated with financial impacts and pressures, such as continuous demands to produce news that is sellable and that attracts potential consumers (Wiik and Andersson 2013; Almiron-Roig 2011). Other factors – 'internal' shifts and transformations inside of the profession – were also indicated as contributing to a much more relaxed view on how today's journalism is defined by the profession and what it appears to be.

All in all, these alterations and challenges encountered in the field of journalism are closely attached to a number of general departures that have recently taken place in contemporary societies. Among those most distinctive is its interactive and networking character (Castells 2001), which, by making great impacts on how social forms and connections are constructed, formed and disintegrate, also greatly affects the field of journalism and communications (Heinrich 2011). A general perspective of modernization fits here. As broadly discussed, contemporary societies and social structures call to be defined as 'liquid' (Bauman 2000) – in a planet crisscrossed by information highways nothing can be credibly assumed to stay within geographic, intellectual or material borders. In such arrangements, society is increasingly viewed and treated as a 'network' rather than a 'solid structure'; even more, in such a society all social forms can no longer keep their shape for long because they decompose, dissolve and disappear faster than the time it takes to build and construct them. In such engagements, the promise is given to individuals to pursue their interests – individuals are now expected to be free choosers, but they must bear in full the consequences of their choices; hence, some scholars also use such notions as 'audience engagement' and 'participatory culture', which clearly put an emphasis on the creative, mutually maintained, shared and productive roles of non-professionals in news media manufacturing routines (Jenkins 2009).

Journalism is and always has been a social phenomenon. It is neither an unbroken, nor a solid and stable thing. Rather, journalism should be viewed as a varied cultural phenomenon and practice which – though having a set of universal professional standards – is still a very national construct dependent on national traditions and circumstances (Hallin and Mancini 2004). As popularly defined, journalism is a knowledge production process that is embedded in a specific and complicated social landscape (Carey 1989). Hence, journalism appears to be a weakly autonomous field, so whatever is exceptional and specific about journalism must be continuously constructed, formed and re-created (Carlson 2015; Hayes et al. 2007).

As illustrated, journalism's boundaries and social borders have been profoundly relaxed and loosened by technological means and economic conditions, and stirred by political and social developments and transformations (see Figure 12.1).

First and foremost, the journalistic field was seriously challenged by the ongoing diffusion of interactive technologies, digitization of messages and processes of distribution and convergence of media formats. As seen from thorough reviews of new technologies' influences on journalistic routines, challenges in the profession are indeed overwhelming. Interactive news production democratizes representations by making the process a more direct relationship (Balcytiené et al. 2011). As citizens gain access to inexpensive communication technologies, the gatekeeping monopoly once enjoyed by editors and broadcasters is waning (Raeymaeckers et al. 2014; Gurevitz et al. 2009; Coleman 2005). Even more, the Internet has brought communication to a much more personalized level. Still, not only technological improvements and calls for innovative approaches in news production have pressured media industries and journalism practices worldwide. The technological advancements must be considered as bringing consequences of long-term effects. In addition to changes in reduced news cycles and increasing pressures on journalists to multitask while performing their daily routines, the institutionalization (and silent legitimization) of 'copy-paste journalism' as well as other developments (such as the acceptance of new actors and business formats) have posed the most worrisome questions.


(Continues...)
Excerpted from Comparative Media Policy, Regulation and Governance in Europe by Leen d'Haenens, Helena Sousa, Josef Trappel. Copyright © 2018 Intellect Ltd. Excerpted by permission of Intellect Ltd.
All rights reserved. No part of this excerpt may be reproduced or reprinted without permission in writing from the publisher.
Excerpts are provided by Dial-A-Book Inc. solely for the personal use of visitors to this web site.

"About this title" may belong to another edition of this title.