Methodological Validity Frequency Seriation by Mcnutt Charles (2 results)
Language: English
Published by Society for American Archaeology, Washington, D.C.,
- Softcover
Seller: Legacy Books, Louisville, KY, U.S.A.Legacy Books
Contact seller5-star sellerCondition: Used - Very good
£ 3.15
£ 5.60 shippingShips within U.S.A.Quantity: 1 available
Soft cover. Condition: Very Good. pp45-60, tables. Removed from AMERICAN ANTIQUITY. JOURNAL OF THE SOCIETY FOR AMERICAN ARCHAEOLOGY, Volume 38, Number 1, January, 1973. Wrps. VG. May contain a first or last xeroxed page. Abstract: "Frequency seriation has often led to valid ordering of archaeological data, yet critiques of the t…echnique, and in particular of the construction of unimodal popularity (battleship) curves, have appeared periodically for almost 20 yr. Problems of type definition, collection manipulation and chronological inference have been emphasized. It is here suggested that, above and beyond these difficulties of execution and interpretation, frequency seriation is methodologically unsound: that the battleship curve concept is self-contradictory; that a type/collection frequency has descriptive value only within a collection but has no comparative value between collections; that the most commonplace kinds of ceramic variation can negate the type/collection unimodal curve; that seriation of collections to conform to the self-contradictory battleship curve provides a mechanical method by which significant changes in ceramic complexes may be obfuscated. If this basic form of frequency seriation is methodologically invalid, then more complex schemes for manipulating type/collection frequencies using the same or equivalent assumptions (for example, the Brainerd-Robinson technique and others) are also methodologically suspect.".
Published by Society for American Archaeology, Washington DC, 1973
- Softcover
- First Edition
- Periodical
Seller: The Book Collector, Inc. ABAA, ILAB, Fort Worth, TX, U.S.A.The Book Collector, Inc. ABAA, ILAB
Contact seller4-star sellerCondition: Used - Very good
£ 7.69
£ 5.23 shippingShips within U.S.A.Quantity: 1 available
Soft cover. Condition: Very Good. 1st Edition. 45-60 pages with tables and cited references. Quarto (10" x 7") bound in original publisher's wrappers. American Antiquity Volume 38, number 1 complete issue. First edition. Frequency seriation has often led to valid ordering of archaeological data, yet critiques of the technique, a…nd in particular of the construction of unimodal popularity (battleship) curves, have appeared periodically for almost 20 yr. Problems of type definition, collection manipulation, and chronological inference have been emphasized. It is here suggested that, above and beyond these difficulties of execution and interpretation, frequency seriation is methodologically unsound: that the battleship curve concept is self-contradictory; that a type/collection frequency has descriptive value only within a collection but has no comparative value between collections; that the most commonplace kinds of ceramic variation can negate the type/collection unimodal curve; that seriation of collections to conform to the self-contradictory battleship curve provides a mechanical method by which significant changes in ceramic complexes may be obfuscated. If this basic form of frequency seriation is methodologically invalid, then more complex schemes for manipulating type/collection frequencies using the same or equivalent assumptions (for example, the Brainerd-Robinson technique and others) are also methodologically suspect. Condition: Light edge wear, spine sunned, check marks next to content on back wrappers, spotting to wrappers else very good.
