Structures of Judicial Decison Making from Legal Formalism to Critical Theory - Hardcover

Brooks, Roy L.

Hardcover

ISBN 10: 1594601232 ISBN 13: 9781594601231

Publisher: Carolina Academic Pr, 2005

Synopsis

This is a general book on jurisprudence designed for both the novice and more experienced student, which makes it suitable for first-year law students. It is the first book to distinguish and connect traditional theories of judicial decision-making (e.g., legal formalism, textualism, legal realism, and legal process) with critical process (which is critical theory transformed from a theory of legal criticism into a theory of judicial decision-making). Brooks breaks new ground on several other fronts as well he employs an innovative framework that divides judicial decision-making models into the logical method and the policy method; offers a more nuanced conceptualization of judicial policy-formulation in which judges are seen as not only making policy, but also (and more typically) as discovering and vindicating policy; redefines policy-making in a manner that is different from our traditional understanding of the term; and synthesizes critical process into three judicial models: symmetrical, asymmetrical, and hybrid. The book is written in two parts. Part 1 (Traditional Process) discusses five major traditional judicial models, each reflective of either the logical method or the policy method. Part 1 ends with a synthesis of the traditional models (dividing them into three categories), which judges who have used the book find to be most useful. Part 2 (Critical Process) begins with a discussion of critical theory s central theme and operating elements and then transforms these features into a theory of outsider-oriented judicial decision making, something judges can actually use in deciding cases. Critical theory is thus transformed into critical process.

Edition details

• Publisher: Carolina Academic Pr
• Publication date: 2005
• Language: English
• ISBN 10: 1594601232
• ISBN 13: 9781594601231
• Binding: Hardcover
• Edition number: 2
• Number of pages: 380