There's no question that the Old Testament is foundational for the New Testament church. But foundational or not, it can be difficult for preachers to pin down useful resources for narrative texts within the Old Testament, much less to skillfully preach those passages to their congregations. Benjamin Walton provides the practical insight pastors need. In one volume, he demonstrates both the interpretive and homiletical skills necessary to preach Old Testament narratives well. Walton guides the preacher through selecting a text which is a complete unit of thought; describing the scene in a coherent way; determining the theological message of the text; and carefully crafting a meaningful take-home truth. He doesn't stop with discovering the core message--the majority of the book focuses on delivering the message drawn from these narrative texts. Walton's approach is not just theoretical. It has been read and tested anonymously by groups of pastors, and their feedback has been incorporated into the book. This valuable resource will help preachers put all the pieces together, have confidence in what they're imparting, and maximize their preaching potential for Old Testament narratives.
"synopsis" may belong to another edition of this title.
Benjamin Walton is President of Preachingworks, an organisation helping pastors reaching their preaching potential
Foreword, 17,
Preface, 19,
Introduction, 21,
Abbreviations, 25,
Part I: Discover the Message,
1. OT Narratives, Hermeneutics, and Biblical Authority, 29,
2. OT Narratives: From Text Selection to Take-Home Truth, 45,
3. A Succinct Commentary on 2 Samuel 11–12, 83,
4. Initial Considerations, 91,
5. Create the Introduction, 103,
6. Preach through the CUT (Part 1): Movements, 129,
7. Preach through the CUT (Part 2): Other Options, 139,
8. State the Take-Home Truth, 147,
9. Help Listeners "Buy" the Take-Home Truth, 155,
10. Develop Picture-Painting Applications, 163,
11. Move to Christ, 177,
12. Finishing Well in the Conclusion, 193,
13. From Good to Excellent, 199,
Appendix A: Organic Sermon Structure, 215,
Appendix B: Sermon from 2 Samuel 11–12, 217,
Appendix C: Sermon from Genesis 11:1–9, 231,
Appendix D: Storyline of the Old Testament, 241,
Bibliography, 249,
About the Author, 255,
OT Narratives, Hermeneutics, and Biblical Authority
Accuracy in preaching is vital in today's world. In the 800s, it mattered less if preachers thought the Bible taught the earth was the center of the universe. Everyone believed that. In the 1400s, it mattered less if preachers taught a flat earth. People believed the clergy more than university professors.
Today, when we misinterpret Scripture or assert knowledge of God or his will that the Bible doesn't teach, repercussions can be serious. A few years ago, I had a chance at a college graduation party to witness to a young man who had left the faith years earlier. He was a strip-club bouncer. Knowing that I was a pastor, he asked me a number of Bible questions. My answers shocked him because I was able to show him that the Bible didn't teach much of the well-intentioned legalism he grew up with. No fancy interpretations were necessary. No in-depth analysis was needed — only the most well-accepted, but neglected, principles of biblical interpretation.
What Does It Mean to Preach with Biblical Authority?
Preaching with biblical authority means that our sermons accurately proclaim and apply the message of their biblical preaching texts. It has little to do with whether the sermon is verse-by-verse, topical, or otherwise. It's often called "expository preaching" or "biblical preaching." The benefit of preaching with biblical authority is significant: It renders our message God's message.
Preaching with biblical authority is rooted in the historic Christian belief that God is so different than us that the only reliable way to have knowledge of God or his will is through Scripture. Applied to the sermon, it's the idea that unless the messages we preach and the applications we give derive from the message of our preaching texts, there is a good chance we've misrepresented God.
Preaching with biblical authority has one fundamental problem: It requires preachers. That's you and me. Keith Mathison once observed that no one "asserts that a Bible can enter a pulpit and preach itself. No one asserts that a Bible can read itself. Scripture cannot be interpreted or preached apart from the involvement of some human agency." Since preaching with biblical authority is an action more than a belief, it requires more than a theoretical commitment. It must be put into practice. Despite his profound admiration for us preachers, Haddon Robinson admits that preaching with biblical authority "has suffered severely in the pulpits of those claiming to be its friends."
To preach with biblical authority, we must use sound hermeneutics. Hermeneutics is the thoughtful process of discovering what a biblical text was designed to teach those it was originally written to, so that we can faithfully apply it to our lives today. It recognizes that careful thought is necessary to interpret and apply the Bible. Hermeneutics is necessary to overcome the temptation to too hastily equate our thoughts with God's thoughts. When we preach without giving much thought to hermeneutics, we relegate the Bible to the status of a tool — a tool for us preachers to carry out our agendas, which always seems noble to us.
Hermeneutics 101: How Words and Genre Work Together to Communicate Messages
Sound hermeneutics requires an understanding of how communication works. The Bible, after all, is God's authoritative communication to us. We need to consider three aspects of communication: words, genre, and message. "Words" refers to what we say; "genre" to the way we say it; and "message" to the reason for saying it. When we decide to communicate, we first determine the point we want to make (message); then the way we want to say it (genre); and then finally, we express ourselves in words.
Of these three, genre is the most neglected by preachers. Genre is an essential clue to understanding the message of biblical texts because it clues us in to the reading strategy — i.e., the hermeneutical principles — that the biblical author expects us to use. We practice genre analysis every day. We've all mastered the reading strategies of dozens of genres, including tax bills, political cartoons, parodies, fairy tales, editorials, and street signs. We don't think we're engaging in genre analysis because these genres are common in our culture.
Words alone cannot communicate a message. Genre is necessary to make sense of words. Take the phrase "I am bad." We're familiar with the wording, but what is the message? If intended ironically, it is, "I think I'm cool." If it's a mocking insult, the message is, "The person I'm speaking about thinks he's cool, but he's not." If it's a heartfelt confession, the message is, "I believe that I am a bad person."
In some genres, the words are similar to the message. In others, they are quite different. Let's say we want others to believe that our kids are great. If we want to be crystal clear but dry, we could use a declarative sentence. If we want to "wow" our listeners, we could use an anecdote. If we want to rouse the emotions, we could write a poem. Notice that even when the message is the same, the genre we couch it in affects our word choice:
Genre: Declarative sentence
Words: My kids are great.
Message: Believe my kids are great.
Genre: Anecdote
Words: I woke up, got coffee, heard laughs outside, and saw my kids washing my car.
Message: Believe my kids are great.
Genre: Poem
Words: Roses are red, violets are blue, my kids' hearts are true.
Message: Believe my kids are great.
The same dynamics are present in biblical communication. In some genres, the words are similar to the message; in others, they are very different.
Genre: Direct command (Eph. 5:18a)
Words: Do not get drunk on wine, which is debauchery.
Message: Do not get drunk on alcoholic beverages, which is a public act of wild living.
Genre: Parable (Matt. 13:44)
Words: The kingdom of heaven is like treasure hidden in a field. When found, the finder hides it, sells everything, and buys the field.
Message: Join the kingdom of heaven; it's more valuable than anything else.
Genre: Lament (Ps. 10)
Words: God, why do you hide? The wicked are prospering. God, fix the problem. God is great.
Message: When feeling like God is hiding in the midst of an unjust trial, God's people can (express their feelings to God) call on God to fix the problem; and, when they do, do it while maintaining full confidence that God is great.
Genre: OT narrative (Gen. 11:1–9)
Words: After the flood, people don't disperse, endangering and defying God's redemptive plans, so God disperses them.
Message: It is futile to defy God's redemptive plans, because God's redemptive plans will prevail.
To give an example from recent history: A few years ago, The Da Vinci Code caused quite a stir because many read it more like a work of history than like the novel it is. This was largely a result of the author employing a literary device in its opening pages to heighten interest in the story. The gullible public, unfamiliar with fiction's tools of the trade and unversed in historical Jesus studies, misread the book in droves and made its author a very rich man. If misreading genre clues in secular literature can have deleterious effects, how much more when biblical literature is preached?
Hermeneutics 201: Comparing OT Narratives and NT Epistles
We call the message of a biblical text its theology. This is because the message is from God, and it makes demands on our lives. It includes both the primary and ancillary theological principles that God inspired a text to communicate. A text's message/theology represents the future-oriented direction of the text. In other words, its goal is to get us to conform our lives to it going forward.
Old Testament narratives differ from NT epistles in three key ways. The first is that OT narratives are a form of indirect communication. New Testament epistles are a form of direct communication. The messages of NT epistolary texts are clearer, more straightforward. They often use reason and logic to make their points. Old Testament narratives, however, seek to persuade by enrapturing us in their stories, thereby causing us to lower our defenses, so that their messages can land easily and affectively on our hearts.
The second key difference between OT narratives and NT epistles is that the complete units of thought (CUTs) of OT narratives tend to be one to two chapters in length. The size of NT epistolary CUTs tend to be one to two paragraphs. Identifying CUTs is crucial because they provide the smallest unit of textual context that must be considered when interpreting anything within their boundaries.
The third key difference is that unlike NT epistles, OT narratives do a lot of describing and not a lot of prescribing. That is, they say a lot about what happened and only a little about what should have happened or must happen in the future. Compare 2 Samuel 11:1 with Colossians 2:6 — 7:
2 Samuel 11:1 (OT Narrative)
In the spring of the year, the time when kings go out to battle, David sent Joab, and his servants with him, and all Israel. And they ravaged the Ammonites and besieged Rabbah. But David remained at Jerusalem.
Colossians 2:6–7 (NT Epistle)
Therefore, as you received Christ Jesus the Lord, so walk in him, rooted and built up in him and established in the faith, just as you were taught, abounding in thanksgiving.
It's at this point that an important hermeneutical principle comes into play: "Unless Scripture explicitly tells us we must do something, what is only narrated or described does not function in a normative (i.e., obligatory) way — unless it can be demonstrated on other grounds that the author intended it to function in this way." In other words, it is illegitimate — going beyond the bounds of biblical authority — to turn the individual actions or behaviors that a text describes into principles or commands to be obeyed, unless we can make a really good case for it. Ignoring this hermeneutical principle is called atomistic interpretation
You might be wondering, "How can I know when a described behavior is prescribed?" The answer is: through a careful examination of a combination of factors (1) in a CUT or (2) its book that work together to prescribe the behavior being described. For example, in terms of factors in a CUT, most of 2 Samuel 11 describes David's murderous activities. At the end of the chapter we read, "But the thing that David had done displeased the Lord" (11:27). From this combination of factors, it is accurate to conclude that "murder is wrong, even for the king."
When we take these three key differences between OT narratives and NT epistles together, an important point emerges: OT narratives convey a small number of theological principles. The number of theological principles in one or two chapters of OT narrative pale in comparison to one or two chapters of NT epistle. Plus, as we just saw in the 2 Samuel 11–12 example, it usually takes at least half of a narrative CUT for even ancillary theological principles to be taught.
For preaching, this means that OT narratives contain very few legitimate application principles. What is application? Application is an actionable principle, instruction, or exemplification that derives from the theology (message) of a biblical text. Application is not a universally true or even biblically true idea that comes to our minds when we read or preach a text. Application is not a principle that we "see" illustrated in a text. It is a requirement of God that is prescribed by the passage at hand, or a way to carry out such a requirement. Gordon Fee and Douglas Stuart express it well:
Perhaps the single most useful bit of caution we can give you about reading and learning from narratives is this: Do not be a monkey-see-monkey-do reader [or preacher] of the Bible. ... An Old Testament narrative usually illustrates a doctrine [or behavior] taught propositionally elsewhere. ... Narratives record what happened — not necessarily what should have happened. ... Therefore, not every narrative has an individual identifiable moral application [i.e., a specific behavior that it is advocating or warning against]. ... We are not always told at the end of a narrative whether what happened was good or bad. We are expected to be able to [not apply, but] judge this on the basis of what God has taught us directly and categorically elsewhere in Scripture.
Objection One: Apostolic and Early Church Hermeneutics
I commonly hear two objections when I share that the theology of an OT narrative contains only a small number of application principles. The first cites the hermeneutics of the apostles or early church, suggesting that they had an alternative method of applying OT narratives that we can use today.
Two things can be said in reply. The first, which relates to apostolic hermeneutics, is that if you are willing to dedicate three to five years of your life to sort out and learn the actual hermeneutical methods of the apostles — as opposed to some hack pseudo-version of it — go for it. Don't be surprised, however, when you discover that much of what they did pertained not to discerning life application principles from every nook and cranny of an OT narrative, but to pointing to Christ from the OT.
The second, which relates to the early church's hermeneutics, is that while the early church didn't always recover the message of an OT narrative, it doesn't mean that it wasn't their goal to do so. That many tried and failed doesn't mean that we should fail intentionally. Further, in many ways correct hermeneutics involves what the early church called the "four senses" of Scripture. This way of thinking about the hermeneutical process was dropped not because it was altogether invalid, but because its consistent misapplication yielded highly improbable results.
Objection Two: 1 Corinthians 10:1–22
The second objection that I commonly hear is, "Doesn't the apostle Paul teach in 1 Corinthians 10:1–22, especially 10:6, that we can moralize — i.e., atomistically turn the individual actions of OT narrative characters into 'do or do not do as the biblical character did' principles or commands?" The answer is "no."
There are three ways we can know this. The first way is by carefully reading 1 Corinthians 10:6. Paul — who, in the surrounding context of 10:1–11:1, is warning the Corinthians to avoid idolatry — refers to certain OT narratives that teach the futility of idolatry (i.e., trusting in anything other than God for a sense of national, family, personal, or economic security). As part of that argument, he says in 1 Corinthians 10:6:
"Now these things took place as examples
[tupos:"model, pattern. ... — b. as guidance for a style of life. ... 1 Cor 10:6. ... — c. of someth. serving as a model for understanding someth. else, usually rendered 'type'. ... 1 Cor 10:6]
for us, [so] that we might not desire evil [e.g., idolatry] as they did."
In other words, 1 Corinthians 10:6 teaches that certain OT narratives record Israel's idolatry, so that future generations of people would not follow the overall "model" or "pattern" of idolatry in those narratives. They were written so that we would not be a "type" or "contemporary version" of people who in some sense align ourselves with God, but are in fact idolaters. What Paul is not saying is that OT narratives were written so that we would atomistically make application out of the individual actions of a character.
So then, while it would be legitimate to say, at some point in the sermon, something general like, "Let's be faithful (or not stumble) like Israel in this passage," it would be illegitimate to atomistically turn the specific actions of OT narrative characters into principles or commands to emulate or avoid.
The second way that we can know 1 Corinthians 10:1–22 doesn't teach us to moralize is by looking at the applications that Paul makes. They are: Do not participate in idolatry, particularly of a sexual variety (vv. 7–8); do not put God/Christ to the test (v. 9); do not grumble against God's authority as expressed through the words of his divinely appointed Old Covenant prophets and New Covenant apostles (v. 10); humble yourselves before God (v. 12); believe that God is faithful, enabling victory over temptation (v. 13); flee idolatry (v. 14); people cannot genuinely worship God while still participating in idolatrous practices (v. 21); it is a bad idea to arouse God's jealousy through participation in idolatrous practices because God is stronger than us (v. 22). As we'll see, Paul is not moralizing because he is not atomistically making application out of an action.
For example, Paul's application in 1 Corinthians 10:10 is, "Do not grumble against God's authority." This application derives from either Numbers 14 or 16, it's unclear which. Nonetheless, in both of these chapters, does Israel grumble against God's authority? Yes. Is the application in 1 Corinthians 10:10 that we should not do that same action? Yes. Did Paul moralize? No.
Here's why: As we discussed earlier and illustrated with an example from 2 Samuel 11–12, OT narratives occasionally teach that an action by a character is good or bad. This occurs when a combination of factors in a CUT or its book work together to make that point. In Numbers 14, vv. 19–20 comment on Israel's grumbling in vv. 1–3 and indicate that it was sinful. In Numbers 16, vv. 42–47 contain God's immediate reaction to Israel's grumbling in v. 41, indicating that it too was sinful. Thus Paul's application is legitimate, because a combination of factors working together in the CUT makes that point.
Third, we can know that Paul's applications in 1 Corinthians 10:1–22 are not the result of moralizing because they apply the primary — "trust God alone" — theological principle of their CUTs. The next chapter discusses how to discern that. Before we move on, however, let's reflect on the words of Peter Vogt:
Understanding the author's purposes in writing a narrative helps us avoid a common error in the interpretation of narratives. Many times we approach narratives and look for a readily applicable "moral" that is relevant to our lives. But sound interpretation of the text means seeking to understand the author's intention, not simply looking for something readily applicable. [S]ound interpretation means being content with (or, at least, accepting) the [text on its terms].
Excerpted from Preaching Old Testament Narratives by Benjamin H. Walton. Copyright © 2016 Benjamin H. Walton. Excerpted by permission of Kregel Publications.
All rights reserved. No part of this excerpt may be reproduced or reprinted without permission in writing from the publisher.
Excerpts are provided by Dial-A-Book Inc. solely for the personal use of visitors to this web site.
"About this title" may belong to another edition of this title.
Seller: BargainBookStores, Grand Rapids, MI, U.S.A.
Paperback or Softback. Condition: New. Preaching Old Testament Narratives. Book. Seller Inventory # BBS-9780825442582
Seller: Revaluation Books, Exeter, United Kingdom
Paperback. Condition: Brand New. 256 pages. 8.40x5.40x0.60 inches. In Stock. Seller Inventory # 0825442583
Quantity: 1 available