Electing Judges: The Surprising Effects of Campaigning on Judicial Legitimacy (Chicago Studies in American Politics) - Softcover

Gibson, James L.

Softcover

ISBN 10: 0226291081 ISBN 13: 9780226291086

Publisher: University of Chicago Press, 2012

Synopsis

In Electing Judges, leading judicial politics scholar James L. Gibson responds tothe growing chorus of critics who fear that the politics of running for office undermine judicial independence and even the rule of law. While many people have opinions on the topic, few have supported them with actual empirical evidence. Gibson rectifies this situation, offering the most systematic and comprehensive study to date of the impact of campaigns on public perceptions of fairness, impartiality, and the legitimacy of elected state courts—and his findings are both counterintuitive and controversial.

Gibson finds that ordinary Americans do not conclude from campaign promises that judges are incapable of making impartial decisions. Instead, he shows, they understand the process of deciding cases to be an exercise in policy making, rather than of simply applying laws to individual cases—and consequently think it’s important for candidates to reveal where they stand on important issues. Negative advertising also turns out to have a limited effect on perceptions of judicial legitimacy, though the same cannot be said for widely hated campaign contributions.

Taking both the good and bad into consideration, Gibson argues persuasively that elections are ultimately beneficial in boosting the institutional legitimacy of courts, despite the slight negative effects of some campaign activities. Electing Judges will initiate a lively debate inside both the halls of justice and the academy.

About this title

Review

An important work full of insights and surprises--and one that has significant policy implications.--Lawrence M. Friedman, Stanford Law School

Judicial independence is one of our most sacred institutional values, and the means of securing it in state courts has been a source of continuing debate. Gibson's writing is superb, distilling arcane analytical and theoretical issues to show that, contrary to widely held views, people are more willing to accept the decisions of judges when they have the power to reject those who perform poorly, and thus elections build rather than corrode legitimacy. "Electing Judges" is a monumental achievement.
--Paul Brace, Rice University

"Electing Judges" represents a perfect nexus between theoretically driven political science scholarship and real-world politics. Using evidence from survey experiments while remaining agnostic in the normative debate, Gibson disproves the conventional wisdom about how Americans perceive judges, courts, and the judicial selection process. This superbly crafted work should be the cornerstone of any serious discussion of judicial power and institutional reform.
--Melinda Gann Hall, Michigan State University

"An important work full of insights and surprises--and one that has significant policy implications."--Lawrence M. Friedman, Stanford Law School

""Electing Judges" represents a perfect nexus between theoretically driven political science scholarship and real-world politics. Using evidence from survey experiments while remaining agnostic in the normative debate, Gibson disproves the conventional wisdom about how Americans perceive judges, courts, and the judicial selection process. This superbly crafted work should be the cornerstone of any serious discussion of judicial power and institutional reform."--Melinda Gann Hall, Michigan State University

"This careful study dispels a number of myths about popular attitudes toward the courts and is a major contribution to the debate over state judicial selection. A number of states are currently reconsidering how they select their judges. Gibson's careful study can--and should-make a significant contribution to those deliberations."
--G. Alan Tarr"Library of Law and Liberty" (06/20/2013)

"Although there have been many doomsday scenarios put forth by those opposed to judicial elections, there is virtually no empirical evidence--positive or negative--regarding the effects of politicized judicial campaigns on judicial legitimacy. Enter James L. Gibson's book, "Electing Judges." Using both experimental vignettes and panel surveys, Gibson has written one of the most important books on the effects of judicial elections. Indeed, it may be "the" most important book on the topic since Dubois's "From Ballot to Bench.""--Matthew J. Streb, Northern Illinois University"Political Communication" (05/07/2013)

"An important work full of insights and surprises and one that has significant policy implications."--Lawrence M. Friedman, Stanford Law School"

"Judicial independence is one of our most sacred institutional values, and the means of securing it in state courts has been a source of continuing debate. Gibson s writing is superb, distilling arcane analytical and theoretical issues to show that, contrary to widely held views, people are more willing to accept the decisions of judges when they have the power to reject those who perform poorly, and thus elections build rather than corrode legitimacy. "Electing Judges" is a monumental achievement."--Paul Brace, Rice University"

James L. Gibson is an intellectual giant in the field of judicial politics, and "Electing Judges" may be his most important contribution to date. This is a first-rate piece of scholarship that speaks directly to the central arguments in a highly contentious ongoing debate. For all interested in the judicial selection process, Gibson s evidence is powerful and simply cannot be ignored.--Chris W. Bonneau, University of Pittsburgh"

About the Author

James L. Gibson is the Sidney W. Souers Professor of Government at Washington University in St. Louis and Professor Extraordinary in Political Science at Stellenbosch University in South Africa. He is the author or coauthor of eight books, including Citizens, Courts, and Confirmations.

About this edition

• Publisher: University of Chicago Press
• Publication date: 2012
• ISBN 10: 0226291081
• ISBN 13: 9780226291086
• Binding: Paperback
• Number of pages: 240