God of Battles: Holy Wars of Christianity and Islam: Holy Wars of East and West - Hardcover

Partner, Peter

Hardcover

ISBN 10: 0002555670 ISBN 13: 9780002555678

Publisher: HarperCollins, 1997

Synopsis

An examination of the ways in which the concept of holy war - the jihad of the East and the crusade of the West - came to acquire the symbolic power it has, and how this still affects the modern world. It shows how the ideals of the crusade permeated Western attitudes, traditions and beliefs, and how this influence still persists today. It discusses the modernity or otherwise of today's Islamic fundamentalist movements and the meaning they give to the concept of jihad. It argues that Christianity has never been a pacifist religion and that the institution of the crusade was central to the policies, prestige and world view of the papacy and many European states. It reveals how present-day Islamic reformers have actually borrowed from the vocabulary of fundamentalism from Western sources, while maintaining their faithfulness to their own traditions and discusses the ways in which they have interpreted the idea of holy war. Above all, it investigates the reasons behind the fear which Islamic fundamentalism excites in the West and warns against allowing views that ultimately derive from 11th-century propoganda to infuence us today.

About this title

Review

ÝPeter Partner¨ is just the man to provide a rational examination of the past ... a healthy antidote to the customary media debates about 'terrorism.' -- Richard Gott "Literary Review"

Partner writes with impressive sensitivity towards the subjects he is discussing. He is aware of the need to view different situations in their own contexts.... This book replaces caricature with a sympathetic, though not unduly flattering portrait.--David Edgar "Irish Times "

[Peter Partner] is just the man to provide a rational examination of the past ... a healthy antidote to the customary media debates about 'terrorism.'--Richard Gott "Literary Review "

The best part of this excellent book concerns the shifting traditions of Islam in the nineteenth and twentieth century.... This is the only book I have read that comes to a fair and intelligent judgement on the Ayatollah Khomeini.--Andrew Wheatcroft "Sunday Times "
The best part of this excellent book concerns the shifting traditions of
Islam in the nineteenth and twentieth century.... This is the only book I
have read that comes to a fair and intelligent judgement on the Ayatollah
Khomeini.
--Andrew Wheatcroft "Sunday Times "
Partner writes with impressive sensitivity towards the subjects he is
discussing. He is aware of the need to view different situations in their
own contexts.... This book replaces caricature with a sympathetic, though
not unduly flattering portrait.
--David Edgar "Irish Times "
[Peter Partner] is just the man to provide a rational examination of the
past ... a healthy antidote to the customary media debates about
'terrorism.'
--Richard Gott "Literary Review "

"The best part of this excellent book concerns the shifting traditions of Islam in the nineteenth and twentieth century.... This is the only book I have read that comes to a fair and intelligent judgement on the Ayatollah Khomeini."--Andrew Wheatcroft, Sunday Times

"Partner writes with impressive sensitivity towards the subjects he is discussing. He is aware of the need to view different situations in their own contexts.... This book replaces caricature with a sympathetic, though not unduly flattering portrait."--David Edgar, Irish Times

"[Peter Partner] is just the man to provide a rational examination of the past ... a healthy antidote to the customary media debates about 'terrorism.'"--Richard Gott, Literary Review

From the Back Cover

What makes a war 'holy', and who decides that it is? In this wide-ranging and thought-provoking book, Peter Partner examines the origins of holy war, the ways in which it acquired its symbolic power, and how it still affects the modern world. From the pre-Christian era to the Gulf War, from Deuteronomy to 'The Satanic Verses', 'God of Battles' places the 'jihad' of the East and the crusade of the West in their historical context, and warns against allowing views that ultimately derive from crusading war propaganda to affect our judgements today.

Despite its pacifist message, Christianity has always been one of the great warrior religions. Partner shows how the ideal of the crusade, 'God's war', came to permeate medieval Christendom, and how powerfully it influenced later Western societies, especially in their attitudes to colonialism. He investigates today's Islamic fundamentalist movements, the meaning they attach to 'jihad' and the occasions on which they have practised it. He reveals how, while traditional in some respects, they are very modern in others, borrowing the most important part of their political vocabulary from Western sources. He also explores the pragmatism about waging holy war that has always influenced both Christianity and Islam.

Above all, 'God of Battles' examines the reasons behind the fear which Islamic fundamentalism excites in the West. Peter Partner argues that the only way to deprive holy war of its frightening aura of fanaticism is to look afresh at its religious framework and its political and social history. It is widely believed that only in the Muslim case can holy war be considered as an element in present-day conflicts, but crusading has in fact had a much longer afterlife than is generally thought, and its attitudes, that we think of as long-dead, continue to influence us, just as parallel religious ideas influence the Muslim world.

Peter Partner worked for many years as a journalist, for the 'Observer' (for whom he wrote the leading article in the first week of Suez) and the 'Economist' among others. He has broadcast frequently for the BBC on Arab topics. His books include 'The Lands of St Peter: The Papal State in the Middle Ages', 'The Murdered Magicians: The Templars and their Myth' and 'The Pope's Men: The Papal Civil Service in the Renaissance'. He lives in Winchester.

About this edition

• Publisher: HarperCollins
• Publication date: 1997
• ISBN 10: 0002555670
• ISBN 13: 9780002555678
• Binding: Hardcover
• Number of pages: 496